There was much talk yesterday, Wednesday, September 6,2006, on all the Talk Shows in Jamaica, concerning Jamaican Prime Minister (PM) Portia Simpson Miller's inability to properly respond to Bruce Golding's (Jamaica's Opposition Leader) questions re the Sandals Whitehouse Report in Parliament on Tuesday, Sept 5,2006.
The Sandals Whitehouse Project had a USD $41 million (JMD $2.7 billion) budget overrun which the developers (the Urban Development Corporation and Gorstew Limited) claimed was due to its original plan being modified to be in compliance with the standards set for all Sandals Hotels under the Breezes brand. (Sandals and Breezes Hotel Brands are owned by hotelier, Gordon "Butch" Stewart).
The Hotel Project was first projected to cost USD $70 million or JMD $4.6 billion.
The Report (requested by the Opposition to investigate the overruns) claimed that the hotel could have been built for USD $88 million (JMD $5.8 billion), based on what the surveyors saw "on the ground". Instead, the total cost was USD $111 million (JMD $7.3 billion).
The PM said that the tax-paying Jamaican public wouldn't have to worry about the overrun, since the revenues coming in during the summer months from Sandals Whitehouse, would more than offset the USD $41 million budget overrun.
When she was asked to quantify those revenues...she couldn't, and fumbled for about 10 seconds before she could give the Opposition Leader an answer. And to add insult to injury, when she was finally able to proffer a response, she told Mr. Golding that he should direct his questions to Dr. Omar Davies, the Finance Minister.
Mr. Golding then asked how comes she was telling the Jamaican public that the revenues would offset the USD $41million, when she had no idea of what these revenues were?
She then kept on re-iterating that she is in charge, but that she can't know everything, that's why she had Ministers in charge of different portfolios.
People are saying that the reason for the PM's guffaw, was that maybe she wasn't properly briefed about the situation..then we're hearing that she doesn't read her briefs.
Well, whatever the truth is of the situation, when the guffaw was aired on TV on Tuesday night,the Prime Minister looked incompetent, as, in addition to her fumbling, she was constantly being coached by Dr. Omar Davies re how to respond to Mr. Golding's questions.
Speaking of adding insult to injury...
What annoyed a lot of people is that the consultants took 10 months to come up with the Report and at the end of it all, slapped the Jamaican public with a USD $394,896,000 (JMD $26 million) bill for it. For all of 1000 pages.
As far as I can see, the Prime Minister is in a dilemma...
There has always been an issue raised about this lady's educational acumen, despite her scoring higher than Mr. Golding in the latest Stone Polls (Jamaican pollsters renown for their accuracy) re her knowledge (of what, the polls didn't make clear).
For the life of me, I can't figure out why our PM, should allow guffaws like this to happen when people within her own party and outside of it, are just waiting for her to fail.
She is the first female Jamaican PM, but being a woman will not be enough for her to excel in this position. I think she has to decide to work four times as hard, to excel as PM, knowing that the decks are stacked against her.
This phenomenon of a woman having to prove herself isn't new, as it's still a man's world, and for a woman to make it to the top, she has to be twice to four times as good as any man vying for the position.
What do I think PM Portia Simpson-Miller needs to do to demonstrate that she is really in charge of the government and country she leads?
1) She needs to run Jamaica like she's running a company, as Tony Laing (Jamaican Musicologist) would say... This means that she needs to be willing to make hard decisions...like requesting that her Ministers step down after repeated instances of failure and them overseeing projects in which there is misuse of public funds.
2) She needs to read biographies of successful PMs and Presidents and see how they addressed and overcame the challenges their nations faced.
3) She needs to read biographies of successful female presidents of companies, to see how they overcame the stigma of being a female boss and how they successfully led their companies to market leadership despite harsh economic conditions.
4) She needs to apply all the knowledge gained from her readings.
Doing the above will ensure that she is always aware of her responsibilities as a PM and that she's always two steps ahead of her possible detractors.
Please see the following links about this story, from articles from the Jamaica Gleaner (one of Jamaica's leading newspapers):
1. Sandals Whitehouse probe - 'Cost overruns due largely to change in scope of works', July 27, 2006
http://www.jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/20060727/news/news1.html
2. Noel Hylton denies submitting Sandals Whitehouse Report, August 21,2006.
http://www.jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/20060821/lead/lead6.html
3. Editorial: That Whitehouse debacle, September 7,2006.
http://www.jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/20060907/cleisure/cleisure1.html
Recent Comments