Are Investment Schemes Really Credible Investment Alternatives to Banks?
Friends, let's face it...you work hard and smart for your money...so your money should be working hard and smart, for you :).
The reality is that money in the bank is really just a safety net (for emergencies and other necessities),few banks will give you the returns on your money that will even cover inflation (the percentage increase in prices over a month or a year), much less take care of you, during your retirement.
So you have to find other investment instruments that will give you enough returns on your original investment to protect you against inflation, take care of some of your current needs and take care of you while you're aging.
(If you do enough research and/or speak with your certified financial advisor, you will find instruments and pension funds that will do so, while attracting very little or no taxes, on the increases/gains on your original investment.)
Traditional investment instruments include stocks, bonds, mutual funds, Certificates of Deposit(CDs). (CDs are only issued by banks and savings and loans institutions).
But increasingly, Investment "Schemes" are becoming common in Jamaica. Some claim to invest in the traditional instruments mentioned above, some claim to do foreign exchange (forex) trading.
Those that do forex trading claim to be very good at it...so good that they can give their investors returns of up to 18% per month, if "investors" leave their money with them over a certain time period (usually 3-5 years).
I put "investors" in quotes, as these Investment "Schemes" will tell you that they don't offer financial advice, but the money you invest, is really a loan: if you leave the money with them for a certain time period, you'll get phenomenal returns on your investments (e.g. the 18% monthly return,mentioned above).
(NB: that Investment "Schemes" are slightly different from investment clubs. Investment clubs give financial advice and club members are told how their monies are being invested.)
Of course the banks don't even give you 10% annually, so these "Schemes" have become quite attractive to many Jamaicans, wishing to supplement (increase) their incomes.
Since these Investment "Schemes" are not banks, they can't issue money,so they use Commercial Banks to encash cheques drawn on their accounts.(Their customers have to go to these Commercial Banks to get their monthly cheques.)
In Jamaica, over the past two (2) weeks, established banks like the National Commercial Bank (NCB) have been refusing to negotiate cheques drawn on unregistered Investment Schemes like "Cash Plus" (they are either delaying the encashment of Cash Plus customers' cheques, for up to 30 days, or refusing to encash these cheques, altogether)...citing various reasons: from these "Schemes" not disclosing their sources of income, to them not producing audited financial statements - requirements under the "Securities Act" and "Money Laundering Act" that govern Jamaican financial institutions.
There have even been suggestions that some of these 'Schemes" may be fraudulent.
[The Financial Services Commission(FSC), the body that regulates financial intuitions in Jamaica, held a forum, entitled, "The Role of the Investor in Investment Schemes", on Monday, November 26,2007, at the Terra Nova Hotel, in Kingston. They warned Jamaicans to pressure these "schemes" to open their books and produce audited quarterly financial statements.
They advised ordinary Jamaicans to learn how to read these audited statements (balance sheet, profit and loss account, cash flow statement) and to ask questions re how their monies are being invested.
What became clear during the discussions that ensued from this forum, however, is that the FSC is not sure how forex trading operates - they are just learning...they just want these "Schemes" to be transparent with the FSC and investors.]
What is interesting is that these very banks, who conduct foreign exchange (forex) trading, are telling Jamaicans to be wary of forex traders who are unregistered. (Some of the very people who used to trade forex for these banks, have now gone into business themselves, by starting their own Investment "Schemes".)
Why weren't these banks warning Jamaicans five(5) years ago when these "Schemes" came unto the market?
Well, what is being said by people in the "know", is that some of the banks' largest customers are withdrawing their monies and investing them in these "Schemes"...to get the higher returns that ordinary Jamaicans are now making.
The banks' profits are reportedly suffering as a result .
However, for the life of me, I can't see why, if these traders/"Schemes" are transparent, why they haven't applied for registration with the FSC. The cost is USD $71,131.15/JMD $5 million (US $71,131.15/ Jamaican $5 million)...small change for these guys and gals who claim to be making millions daily.
The banks have been warning Jamaicans that these "schemes" have a lifespan of five (5) years...this means they are just at the age when they will crumble.
Well what ordinary Jamaicans are saying, is that the banks have no say in this matter...they never cared about them before (Jamaicans are charged to deposit and withdraw money), so why all of a sudden do they seem to be concerned about their well-being now?
...These Jamaicans can now send their children to university, feed their families, live a decent life, when they couldn't do it before with the poor returns the banks give them.
Jamaicans who are investing in these "Schemes" are telling the banks to "back-off", to stop pressuring these Investment Schemes.
They are telling the banks that since they are so concerned about them, they should be giving them better returns.
They are also saying that they are astute (smart) enough, not to invest all their monies in these "Schemes", but to only invest money they can afford to lose.
Hmmh...
Well, Cash Plus has sued NCB for closing its accounts, and has been making alternative arrangements with overseas banks, to enable Cash Plus clients to get their monthly cheques. (E.g. issuing their clients with credit cards as of December 1, 2007 and wiring the monies from abroad, into their clients' accounts.)
As we speak, ordinary Jamaicans are pooling their monies, to get the required minimum investment amount, needed to enter these "Schemes".
So...are Investment Schemes really credible investment alternatives to banks?
Well, more and more Jamaicans are beginning to think so.
What do you think?
(Please note that the above advice does not substitute for advice from your certified financial advisor.)
Sources Include:
1) Article, "Cash Plus squeezed - 'Suspicious' label delays bank payouts", by Shelly-Ann Thompson, staff Reporter, Jamaica Gleaner, November 23, 2007
2) FSC Forum: "The Role of the Investor in Investment Schemes", November 27, 2007,
3) Article, "Bankers deny 'Cash Plus conspiracy"', Jamaica Gleaner, November 28,2007
4) Nationwide Radio, November 14-28, 2007
5) Power 106 Radio, November 14-28, 2007
6) Laws of Jamaica:The Securities Act, Ministry of Justice, Jamaica, website
7) Laws of Jamaica: The Securities Act (Subsidiary Legislation), Ministry of Justice, Jamaica, website
8) Laws of Jamaica: The Money Laundering Act, Ministry of Justice, Jamaica, website
9) Laws of Jamaica: The Money Laundering Act (Subsidiary Legislation), Ministry of Justice, website
Gillian



















Recent Comments